A Very Key West Holiday Gift Guide

Give the gift of the Key West experience with theater tickets, local wine, craft beer, and spirits, and more. Here’s a very Key West holiday gift guide designed to delight everyone you’re shopping for this holiday season.

Local Wine from Key West Winery

Surprise your resident wine lover this holiday with a tropical fruit wine from Key West Winery. Their best sellers include Hurricane Class 5 Tropical Sangria, Sparkling Key Lime, and Key Lemen, a Florida key lime wine that won a gold medal at the Florida State Fair.

Tickets to a Film at Tropic Cinema

The proudly independent cinema showcases films for those who long for something more than Hollywood blockbusters. Buy tickets for your favorite cinephile to indie films, international favorites, and cinematic classics on the big screen at Tropic Cinema.

A Bottle of Rum from Key West First Legal Rum

Help your loved one build their home bar with a bottle of local rum. Key West’s first legal rum distillery since Prohibition produces award-winning rums aged in Salt Cured Barrels using Florida demerara sugar and naturally-sourced food flavors like Cuban coffee, key lime, and coconut. We recommend starting with their Bad Bitch Spanish Marie Rum, which won Double Gold at the World Wine and Spirits Competition.

A Locally Crafted Cigar

Nothing beats a fine cigar during the holidays. Being only 90 miles from Havana, you’ll find cigars with deep roots in Cuban heritage throughout Key West. Try Key West’s Rodriguez Cigar Factory, Island Cigar Factory, or Greene Street Cigar Company for savory smokes.

Sandals from Kinos

A Key West staple since 1966, Kinos Sandals hand-cuts, assembles, and glues all their sandals in their factory at the corner of Greene and Fitzpatrick Streets. Check out their over 17 different styles using natural leather uppers and rubber soles in person or on their website.

Tickets to a Show at the Key West Theater

Bring the unforgettable magic of live entertainment to someone you know. The performing arts venue hosts musical acts, plays, and performances. View their calendar to see what’s new.

A Candle from Key West Candle Company

The Key West Candle Company sources spent liquor bottles from Ricks, Durty Harry's, Irish Kevins, and Sloppy Joes to use as vessels for their coconut wax candles. Choose from scents like Bahama Village (fresh linens), Cuban Cigar, Key Lime Pie, and Conch Harbor (lemongrass, black currant, patchouli, and sugarcane).

Beauty products from Key West Aloe

Key West Aloe produces the largest selection of aloe-based products in the world. Their luxury beauty products include lip balm, moisturizer, cleanser, sun care, and even a pet care line for your furry friends. Shop online or visit them on Greene Street.

Craft Beer from The Waterfront Brewery

The Waterfront Brewery has a variety of gifts available at their William Street location. Shop socks, koozies, hats, t-shirts, and stainless steel mini kegs to fill on-site with brews like Bigger Boat White, Island Life Lager, and Passionfruit Shandy.

Pastries from Old Town Bakery

Make the holiday feel a bit more nostalgic with delicious pastries from the old fashioned baker on Eaton Street. Old Town Bakery has fresh baked goods like chocolate croissants, raspberry scones, sticky buns, apple cobbler danish, and lemon honey pound cake daily, but expect some fun holiday delights as we move into December.

Local Art from Galleries

Duval Street in particular is lined with galleries. Millionaire Gallery, LIK Fine Art Key West, Effusion Gallery, and Key West Pottery are a few tried-and-true favorites where you can find excellent gifts.

Ring in the holidays with 24 North Hotel in Key West. Book a stay with us for affordable prices, convenient shuttle services to Old Town, and excellent facilities. Check out our rooms here, and look to see which of our online specials work for you.